# Reproducible Model — Automate or Hire? **Status:** Hypothetical scenario. No client outcome has been claimed. Published data and assumptions are separated below. ## Assumptions | Variable | Value | Source status | |---|---:|---| | Baseline monthly cases | 1,800 | Hypothetical | | Forecast monthly cases | 2,400 | Hypothetical | | Existing people | 2 | Hypothetical | | Reliable cases per person per month | 1,000 | Hypothetical, net of normal QA/admin | | Maximum target human utilization | 90% | Hypothetical policy target | | Eligible routine cases / month | 1,000 | Hypothetical | | Workflow resolution of eligible cases | 60% | Hypothetical; must be proven through acceptance | | New hire annual *fully loaded* cash cost | $108,000 | Hypothetical employer estimate | | Workflow implementation fee | $12,000 | Hypothetical, **not published OMEGANEON price** | | Workflow Managed Operations | $4,000/month | Hypothetical, **not published OMEGANEON price** | | Usage, hosting, incremental integration | $600/month | Hypothetical | | Paid Pilot | $4,000/45 days | OMEGANEON planned standard offer, **excluded from this production-year cost model** | ## Formulas and exact values ```text Existing human capacity = 2 × 1,000 = 2,000 cases/month Target human load ceiling = 2,000 × 0.90 = 1,800 cases/month Minimum workflow resolutions needed = 2,400 − 1,800 = 600 cases/month Eligible routine cases = 1,000 / month Workflow resolution threshold = 600 / 1,000 = 60% Forecast volume under hire = 2,400 cases/month Hiring path human utilization = 2,400 / (3 × 1,000) = 80% Automation path human queue = 2,400 − (1,000 × 0.60) = 1,800 cases/month Automation path human utilization = 1,800 / 2,000 = 90% Incremental hire monthly cost = $108,000 / 12 = $9,000 Annual workflow managed = 12 × $4,000 = $48,000 Annual workflow usage/hosting = 12 × $600 = $7,200 First-year workflow cash = $12,000 + $48,000 + $7,200 = $67,200 Year-one incremental cash difference = $108,000 − $67,200 = $40,800 Year-one incremental cost difference percent = $40,800 / $108,000 = 37.777...% Year-two workflow cash, no new implementation = $48,000 + $7,200 = $55,200 Year-two incremental cash difference = $108,000 − $55,200 = $52,800 Monthly operating difference = $9,000 − $4,000 − $600 = $4,400 Simple production-phase cash payback in months = $12,000 / $4,400 = 2.72727... First calendar-month-end crossover = Month 3 Maximum break-even managed monthly price = ($108,000 − $12,000) / 12 − $600 = $7,400 Cumulative savings after production month N = -$12,000 + ($4,400 × N) Month 12 = -$12,000 + $4,400 × 12 = $40,800 ``` ## Key operational sensitivity | Eligible resolution rate | Automated cases | Human load | Human utilization | At/under 90% target? | |---|---:|---:|---:|---| | 30% | 300 | 2,100 | 105% | No | | 40% | 400 | 2,000 | 100% | No | | 50% | 500 | 1,900 | 95% | No | | 60% | 600 | 1,800 | 90% | Yes | | 70% | 700 | 1,700 | 85% | Yes | ## Interpretation / budget treatment - The comparison uses **marginal cost**, not the entire existing support department's spending. Both alternatives retain the two current employees and their shared tools. - The $108,000 annual avoided hire is a cash saving **only if a real hire would otherwise have been funded and the team meets the measured service target**. Otherwise use “incremental capacity created” rather than “saved payroll.” - Month 0–12 in Figure 3 begins at **production start**, with implementation booked at Month 0. It excludes pilot expense, integration/ramp delays, legal fees, taxes on vendors, and any parallel transition cash; add those once known. - BLS compensation data describe actual economy-wide averages; do not multiply annual salary by BLS benefit share without adjusting the denominator. The example uses one explicitly fully loaded $108k input. - The QJE 15% observation measures **issues resolved per hour by support agents using AI assistance**, not the workflow's hypothetical 60% eligible-resolution rate. - Response time, escalations, reopened tickets, compliance gates and override rates are essential acceptance metrics. Pass/fail is conditional on those measures. ## Empirical anchors - BLS ECEC, June 2026: $46.89/hour average employer compensation in private industry ($32.82 wages + $14.07 benefits). https://www.bls.gov/news.release/ecec.nr0.htm - BLS June 2026, Professional and Technical Services: $51.88 wages + $24.10 benefits = $75.98/hour total compensation. https://www.bls.gov/charts/employer-costs-for-employee-compensation/costs-by-industry.htm - Brynjolfsson, Li and Raymond, *Generative AI at Work* (QJE, 2025): 5,172 agents; +15% average issues resolved/hour with AI assistant. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjae044