# REVBEEP — Bottom-Up Time-Motion Benchmark

## Model and Results

### From procurement data to faster pursuit decisions

REVBEEP automates routine procurement ingestion and first-pass triage, prepares evidence-linked qualifications, and leaves pursuit authorization with human reviewers. The **actual REVBEEP review benchmark is 10–15 minutes per target RFP**; routine automated triage requires **0 human hours**. Machine execution, escalated exceptions, and formal proposal preparation are separate from that human review measure.

### Outcome dashboard

| Measure | REVBEEP operating result | Measurement boundary |
|---|---:|---|
| Routine weekly opportunity triage | **0 human hours** | Automated first-pass triage; excludes exceptional human interventions |
| Human qualification review | **10–15 min per target RFP** | Evidence-linked decision review, not full proposal production |
| Amendment tracking | **Workflow-driven** | Version-aware change detection and reassessment |
| Decision record | **Evidence-linked** | Source context, qualification result, action and authorized decision |

### Independent Time-Motion Decomposition (GOMS-Informed)

This bottom-up model estimates each operator action **before calculating the final totals**. It does not distribute predetermined total hours across tasks. The manual and aggregator estimates are scenario-specific calculations, while REVBEEP's 10–15-minute review figure is the separately established operating benchmark.

**Fixed comparison workload:** 60 new procurement notices/week → 12 selected for basic eligibility review → 2 target RFPs/week for deeper qualification. One workweek is five business days. The target RFP is moderately complex, with a main solicitation and supporting material. The comparison counts **human active working time**, not unattended processing or formal proposal writing. Saved searches are allowed for manual portals; commercial platforms are modeled with saved searches **and current AI-assisted features**, rather than pretending they are purely manual.

#### A. Weekly opportunity triage — action-by-action estimate

| # | Comparable human activity | Manual portals (min/week) | AI-assisted commercial aggregator (min/week) |
|---:|---|---:|---:|
| 1 | Check searches, adjust filters and source scope | 12–25 | 4–8 |
| 2 | Review 60 new notices (manual: 1–2 min each; assisted: 15–45 sec each) | 60–120 | 15–45 |
| 3 | Open and skim 12 shortlisted notices (manual: 4–8 min each; assisted: 2–4 min each) | 48–96 | 24–48 |
| 4 | Check basic eligibility on 12 candidates (manual: 3–6 min each; assisted: 1–3 min each) | 36–72 | 12–36 |
| 5 | Deduplicate and rank the candidate set | 12–25 | 6–14 |
| 6 | Prepare and share the shortlist | 15–30 | 8–15 |
| **TOTAL** | **Independent action sum** | **183–368 min (3h 03m–6h 08m)** | **69–166 min (1h 09m–2h 46m)** |

**REVBEEP:** Routine first-pass ingestion, filtering, and candidate prioritization are automated (**0 routine human minutes/week**). Any exceptional manual intervention is recorded separately.

#### B. Deep-dive qualification — action-by-action estimate

**Unit:** One target RFP already selected from the weekly triage. The initial skim and basic eligibility check in Section A are **not repeated** here. This stage covers detailed qualification and a bid/no-bid brief, not writing or submitting the final proposal.

| # | Comparable human activity | Manual portals (min/RFP) | AI-assisted commercial aggregator (min/RFP) |
|---:|---|---:|---:|
| 1 | Retrieve relevant documents and inspect the attachment set | 8–15 | 3–8 |
| 2 | Read detailed scope, deliverables and material attachments | 40–80 | 15–35 |
| 3 | Extract hard eligibility and compliance requirements | 20–50 | 10–25 |
| 4 | Research historical awards, incumbents and agency buying context | 20–45 | 8–20 |
| 5 | Match required capabilities with past performance and delivery capacity | 20–45 | 10–25 |
| 6 | Compile and check the pursuit decision brief | 20–40 | 8–20 |
| 7 | Review and record the pursuit recommendation | 10–20 | 8–15 |
| **TOTAL** | **Independent action sum** | **138–295 min (2h 18m–4h 55m)** | **62–148 min (1h 02m–2h 28m)** |

#### C. REVBEEP — human decision review

The machine prepares the underlying research and evidence-linked brief. The human review can be decomposed independently as follows:

| # | Human action | Estimated min/RFP |
|---:|---|---:|
| 1 | Open the brief and understand the recommendation | 1–2 |
| 2 | Check critical fit, requirements and risks | 3–5 |
| 3 | Spot-check material evidence references | 3–5 |
| 4 | Record GO / NO-GO / WATCH / VERIFY / PARTNER | 2–4 |
| **INDEPENDENT MODEL TOTAL** | **Expected routine human review** | **9–16 min/RFP** |
| **REVBEEP OPERATING BENCHMARK** | **Previously established actual human review** | **10–15 min/RFP** |

The independent 9–16-minute estimate and the recorded 10–15-minute operating benchmark are **two separate lines of evidence**. Complex exceptions are handled as additional work rather than silently included in routine review.

#### D. Weekly capacity model

Let **N** be the number of target RFPs receiving deep-dive qualification in a week. With the fixed 60-notice screening scope, total **human time** is:

```text
Manual portals:             [183 + 138N, 368 + 295N] minutes/week
AI-enabled aggregator:      [ 69 +  62N, 166 + 148N] minutes/week
REVBEEP (actual benchmark): [     10N,       15N] minutes/week
```

For **N = 2** target RFPs per week:

| Workflow | Weekly triage | 2 × detailed qualification | **Total weekly human time** |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Manual portals | 183–368 min | 276–590 min | **459–958 min (7h 39m–15h 58m)** |
| AI-enabled aggregator | 69–166 min | 124–296 min | **193–462 min (3h 13m–7h 42m)** |
| **REVBEEP** | **0 min** | **20–30 min** | **20–30 min** |

**Derived human-time differences, two-RFP scenario:** REVBEEP leaves **7h 09m–15h 38m** less manual work than the modeled portal workflow and **2h 43m–7h 22m** less than the modeled AI-enabled aggregator workflow. These differences are **scenario calculations, not an additional production experiment**.

**Per-RFP reduction against this independent task model (using REVBEEP's actual 10–15 min benchmark):**

- Versus manual portals: **89.1%–96.6%** less human time.
- Versus AI-assisted commercial aggregator: **75.8%–93.2%** less human time.

The percentages use conservative endpoints: `1 − 15/138` through `1 − 10/295`, and `1 − 15/62` through `1 − 10/148`. They are calculations from modeled competitor workflows and REVBEEP's reported human review time—not direct, matched real-world trials.

#### E. Previously established Industry Effort Benchmark (retained)

The separately provided **real industry effort benchmarks** remain intact. They are not the totals used to derive Sections A–D.

| Operational activity | Manual portals | Commercial aggregators | REVBEEP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weekly opportunity triage | **5–10 hrs/week** | **3–5 hrs/week** | **0 routine human hrs/week** |
| Deep-dive qualification per RFP | **3–6 hrs** | **1.5–3 hrs** | **10–15 min human review** |
| Amendment/re-compete tracking | Manual spreadsheet checks | Alerts and analyst re-evaluation | Event-driven requalification |

The older benchmark and the new bottom-up estimate describe **different evidence categories and workload assumptions**. Keeping both makes the comparison auditable without forcing task estimates to reproduce a known total. At higher notice volumes and more complex RFPs, working time increases; at lower volumes, it decreases.

#### F. Flow and measurement controls

```mermaid
flowchart LR
  A[60 procurement notices] --> B{Research approach}
  B --> M[Manual portals: 183–368 min triage]
  B --> C[AI aggregator: 69–166 min triage]
  B --> R[REVBEEP: 0 human min routine triage]
  M --> D[12 shortlisted candidates]
  C --> D
  R --> D
  D --> E[2 target RFPs]
  E --> F[Detailed qualification]
  F --> G[Authorized pursuit decision]
```

**Internal measurement fields:** week, source scope, raw notices, shortlisted notices, selected RFPs, document complexity, operator, action start/end times, workflow run ID, exception count and length, evidence version, approval result, and cloud operating cost. Use recorded stopwatch/task-timestamp evidence for subsequent observed cohorts.

### Engineering and operating outcomes

REVBEEP's built system combines a canonical procurement model, evidence-linked qualification, version-aware decision records, background workflow execution, and continuing operating controls.

| Delivered capability | Operational function |
|---|---|
| Canonical procurement objects | Connect opportunities, agencies, awards, companies, and requirements |
| Evidence Ledger | Keep material qualification claims traceable to sources |
| AI + deterministic qualification | Prepare decision-ready intelligence with explicit checks |
| Human approval and recorded decisions | Preserve business authority over pursuit actions |
| Version-aware workflow | Reassess material changes using current evidence |
| Monitored runtime and recovery paths | Support continuing operation, incident handling and maintenance |

**Business outcome:** REVBEEP moves routine procurement research into automated workflow execution and concentrates human time on reviewing evidence-backed opportunities and making pursuit decisions.

---
